Last week we met a church member—let’s call him Alan—who joined AA in an effort to break the grip of alcoholism in his life.
In time, he felt more connected to AA than to church, and he eventually stopped attending the church community altogether. We began exploring what AA does that the church doesn’t.
What’s the appeal? Or the greater point I want to make, what important and useful practices can we find in AA that actually started in the church, but have been mostly abandoned?
This first component we found was this: All are wounded. If you missed it, pop back a week on this blog and catch up.
This week, let’s look at confession.
There’s a great scene in the opening moments of the movie P.S. I Love You, in which a young married couple is walking home to their small New York apartment. The wife is clearly unhappy, strutting angrily ahead of her husband, refusing to say a word.
He, on the other hand, is talking incessantly, trying to get her to speak, trying to figure out what he’s done wrong, knowing that she’s mad about something even though he’s totally clueless as to what it is.
Finally he says, “Are you sure I did something wrong?”
She glares at him.
Then he responds, “You’re right. You’re right. I did it. I’m sure I did it. And I’m sorry. But can’t you at least tell me what it is?”
She’s not buying this apology. Her reasoning? How can you truly be sorry for something when you don’t even know what it is? She doesn’t want him to just be sorry. She wants him to name what he’s sorry for—to know that he gets it.
I love confession. Taking my sins before God daily gives me a reminder of who I truly am, which has two wonderful components in the answer.
I’m flawed.
And I’m His.
Both are places that define me and of which I need daily reminders. I’m so sorry to see that confession has left the protestant church tradition. And I think its loss is AA’s gain. Confession is something AA does rather well. When you’re at an AA meeting, there is a clear presumption that everyone has a story. Everyone has a transgression on their record. Everyone has something to confess. You can’t miss it.
Each week someone stands up and shares their story, their struggles, their errors, and their journey. And if you are sitting there, knowing that you too have struggles like those you’re hearing, you will know you have found a home.
The loss of a public confession in church practice brings a hidden message with it.
Typically, we only see confession in major church disciplinary actions, if then. And it leads people in the pews to believe few have anything to confess, and then only if they’ve had some major moral failure. But the truth is that each of us, every day, does something that makes it so very clear that we are nowhere near the goodness that is God.
Instead of rejoicing with a sister who has had a blessing, I am jealous. Instead of speaking up when someone is maligned as the butt of a joke, I remain silent. Instead of turning away when gossip is offered to me, I listen.
Confession, whether in smaller matters or in larger, is part of the process of repentance and regeneration. It’s a lovely idea. But I don’t say this simply because it’s a nice thing to do.
Then I acknowledged my sin to you and did not cover up my iniquity. I said, “I will confess my transgressions to the LORD”—and you forgave the guilt of my sin. Selah—Psalm 32: 5
If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just and will forgive us our sins and purify us from all unrighteousness.—I John 1:9
Therefore confess your sins to each other and pray for each other so that you may be healed.—James 5:16
He who conceals his sins does not prosper, but whoever confesses and renounces them finds mercy.—Proverbs 28:13
When our prodigal children have doubts, or failings, or questions, they often take them outside of the church community. They long for a place to express their confusion, but fear a loss of community if they share it.
But I have to wonder if their need to take it elsewhere would not be greatly diminished if they saw others, on a weekly basis, who brought it all to the community of believers, who shared failings and struggles, humbled themselves and made clear their dependence upon God, and who never even considered that their needs would be better met away from the body of Christ.
What about you?
Do you think the church needs a confession vehicle?
Do you think your church would be a safe place to stand up and say, “Here’s what I’ve done wrong?”
Is there anything we can do, without constructing a confessional booth, that would make those struggling with real issues feel more able to bring their needs and failings to the church body?